Leaderboard/Fine hair, oily roots/ingredient effects
Hair type

Fine hair, oily roots

Hair that goes limp and greasy quickly; needs cleansing without weight.

Ingredient Score with vs without it Effect t With Without
PEG-100 Stearate
-449 -16.5 9 287
Steareth-6
-438 -16.0 8 288
Mica
-453 -15.1 6 290
CI 77891
-453 -15.1 6 290
Dimethicone
-408 -13.5 50 246
Sodium Lauroyl Glutamate
+569 +12.5 9 287
Hydroxypropyltrimonium Hydrolyzed Wheat Protein
-565 -11.9 3 293
Zinc PCA
+514 +11.8 18 278
Amodimethicone
-409 -11.7 18 278
Trideceth-10
-339 -11.3 36 260
PEG-45m
-451 -11.3 4 292
TEA-Sulfate
-490 -10.0 5 291
Laureth-23
-378 -9.3 14 282
Retinyl Palmitate
+349 +9.2 3 293
Dimethiconol
-297 -8.8 29 267
TEA-Dodecylbenzenesulfonate
-297 -8.8 29 267
2-Oleamido-1,3-Octadecanediol
-545 -8.1 3 293
Trideceth-3
-397 -8.1 9 287
Caffeine
+347 +7.9 34 262
Zingiber Officinale Root Extract
+322 +7.8 4 292
Acetic Acid
-301 -7.5 18 278
Basic Blue 124
-193 -7.4 3 293
Glycol Stearate
-501 -7.4 3 293
Triethylene Glycol
-236 -7.2 21 275
Glyoxal
+389 +7.0 5 291
Guar Hydroxypropyltrimonium Chloride
-232 -6.9 137 159
Coco-Betaine
-370 -6.7 24 272
Carbomer
-374 -6.5 23 273
Argania Spinosa Kernel Oil
-264 -6.3 17 279
Polyquaternium-39
-226 -6.3 4 292

Effect is the difference in mean score (Elo points) between ranked shampoos that contain the ingredient and those that do not; |t| above about 2 is unlikely to be chance alone.